Call Ahead:
262-646-1016

NOW: Order Online!
View the Menu

PDF Print & Fold Menu
Download


New Menu Items
Congratulations! You've found our "Secret Menu." These delicious items are only know to the real insiders and most feverish Bennolli's addicts! Shhhhh...

Spicy Margherita
For a change of pace, we like to kick up our Margherita pizza by substituting spicy sauce and adding Feta cheese.

Meat Eaters
Italian sausage, pepperoni, bacon, roast chicken, Canadian bacon, onions, spicy garlic tomato sauce and Bennolli’s signature cheese blend...Grrrrowl!

Pepperoni Stack
Mozzarella, a solid layer of pepperoni, topped with more mozzarella, and another layer of pepperoni. Grab some extra napkins!

Fire Breathing Chicken
Spicy Garlic Sauce, mozzarella cheese, roast chicken, smoked bacon, red onions, jalapeños, cilantro, topped with a drizzle of barbecue sauce. This chicken bites back!